Well, the semester is out. Here were the results.
In a class of 16 people. I flunked 6. On my blog, I've heard a lot about education and how it's always had its ups and downs, but I'd like us to consider that ratio if only for a moment. The class required the students to write essays of 3 page length (double spaced) and six of the students could not do that. They were given subjects, they could pick other subjects if they liked, there was a formula written in their book, they could stray from the formula, class lectures, whole nine. Six failed. That's not a product of six people not being able to write; that's a product of six people not being able to think. Out of the remaining 10, 3 received a C- and two of those were actually Ds. These by the way are adults returning to college, half of whom would not have passed, had I not shown mercy, because they couldn't write a three page essay. One woman, when it came time to present her work, simply stood in front of me and said nothing until I let her sit down again (her essay was, by the way, two pages short). One of my students plagiarized ridiculously--I was too busy to track her down, and the school refused to let me use its anti-plagiarism resources because I didn't have a "special clause" in my syllabus.
In the other class, I received two angry emails from students for no reason whatsoever. They just felt that they were justified to berate their teacher because despite their high marks, I wasn't appreciating them enough. I received one email from a student who never did anything but sign up for the course. She wanted to know if I would still pass her. I had one student who had decided that my course was the best place to discuss her hatred of men (non-stop, every comment). And one of my students was and is so bad that he deserves a paragraph of his own.
Every assignment of his required a "special considerations" email. No comment he ever made implied that he had read even a page of one of the books for the class. Out of two questions on the midterm, he botched one by writing about his sister. And for the second esssay in the class, he revised his first essay and turned it in again. Oh yeah, and halfway through the on-line final, he started websurfing (in other words, cheating) and couldn't get back into his test. When I gave him a makeup test, he complained bitterly that I'd changed the questions. I gave him a C- because I never wanted to hear from him again. Since then, he has sent me emails explaining that my grade has hurt his GPA, suggesting that I invented the grade and that mathmatically it was impossible for him to get a C- (he's right, he should have had a D) and basically ossilating between whining at me and insulting me so that I will change his grade.
By the way, I have reported him to the school for harrassment, and as you can imagine, they haven't done anything.
So, I don't know. My hope is that the next group of classes will be a hell of a lot better, but as for the idea that modern education isn't in the shitter, I can't agree. Most of these students should simply be kicked out of college. I don't really know how they made it in. Out of 28 students between two classes, I would have put 11 below the line where they should be in a university at all and that's with what I consider to be pretty low standards (3 page essays are really not that hard to write).
Here's my solution. No student should be allowed to email a professor, ever, for any reason. Any email to a professor made after a grade is given should be cause for expulsion from school. Any formal complaint made about a grade should be taken before a board of professors in that subject and if the decision is not made to change the grade, the student should be given an automatic F in the course. In the case of an existing F, the student should be put on automatic academic probation. In the case of existing academic probation, the student should be expelled.
Entrance into college should require a timed 3 page essay to be written on site. There should be a test on the university's official Student Code of Conduct.
We are, quite simply, allowing bullies and con artists to choose their own grades. We are encouraging cheating and harrassment, and we are accepting illiteracy as a learning disability--certainly not something that should keep someone away from a college education. We have reduced the curriculum to a point where any idiot ought to be able to pass some of the easier classes, and yet, we still have people failing them at amazing rates. I honestly wonder whether we're devolving as a species.
I am so glad to be done with these people.